When I walked in, Bill looked at me and said:
“I'm glad you came by.”
That's rarely how a conversation about an old Porsche begins when good news follows.
Then he told me we had a “boat anchor.”
I looked at him like he was speaking Greek.
Bill showed me the deck of the engine block.
Between cylinders 2 and 3, the aluminum had begun to erode. This wasn't carbon buildup. It wasn't a valve job. It wasn't another seal or bearing we could simply replace.
We had reached the end of this engine.
Elliott later explained that the technically correct repair would involve machining the deck surface, which meant removing the head studs and adding considerably more work and expense. He also offered another approach he had successfully used before: repairing the damaged areas with marine epoxy, flattening the surface and using copper spray on the head gasket.
Bill wasn't comfortable going down that road.
Neither was I.
The whole reason I bought a donor engine was to avoid rebuilding a questionable engine. Spending more money repairing a replacement engine that we already knew had significant problems made very little sense.
Fortunately, Elliott had sold the engine with a warranty against major defects. After seeing what Bill and Don had found, he agreed to take it back.
I asked whether he wanted us to put the head and cam tower back on before I returned it.
His answer:
“No need to reassemble.”
And just like that, the engine I thought was going to save the project was headed back to Blairsville.
During all of this, Bill had been reconsidering the engine that originally came out of my 944.
When I told Elliott the donor was coming back, I mentioned something Bill had said:
He thought he might be able to salvage my original engine.
After everything we'd been through trying to replace it, perhaps the answer had been sitting there all along.