BEFORE IT GOES IN

10 — 50 — 40 — 10

I had a replacement engine. Before putting it into the car, I wanted to know exactly what I had bought.

The engine was home. It was the right configuration, it had run briefly while still in the donor car, and we had seen 200 PSI across all four cylinders.

Everything pointed toward this being the solution.

But after what I had already learned with my original engine, there was no way I was simply going to install a 40-year-old used engine without taking a closer look.

So before doing anything else, I performed a leak-down test.

The numbers weren't what I expected.

Cylinder 1 — 10%
Cylinder 2 — 50%
Cylinder 3 — 40%
Cylinder 4 — 10%

Two cylinders looked encouraging.

Two didn't.

Suddenly those four 200 PSI compression readings from Blairsville didn't feel quite as reassuring.

A Little Trick

Don suggested trying one of his tricks before condemning anything. The assumption was that carbon buildup might be preventing the valves from fully seating.

With air pressure applied to the cylinder, he lightly tapped the valve stem, hoping to knock loose whatever might be keeping the valve from sealing.

Cylinder 3 responded almost immediately.

50... tap, tap... 35... tap, tap... 15.

That was encouraging.

Cylinder 2 wasn't nearly as cooperative.

Tap, tap. Nothing.

It stayed around 40%.

If we were going to use this engine, the head was coming off.

Off With Its Head

Once the cylinder head came off, the carbon buildup was obvious. At least we had an explanation for what we'd been seeing.

The engine was going to need a valve job, but that was manageable. Parts were ordered and we kept moving forward.

With the engine already on the stand, Don continued disassembling it so we could replace seals and address anything else that made sense before installation.

Then the oil pan came off.

On the bottom of the oil pickup was a mysterious black blob of something.

Never a particularly reassuring discovery inside an engine.

Bill and Don suggested that since we were already this far into it, we should consider doing the piston rods and rings as well.

And all I could think was:

What else?

THE CALL I DIDN'T EXPECT

“I'm Glad You Came By.”

I was traveling for work and landed back in Atlanta around 11:30 that morning. Since I was already nearby, I decided to swing by German Automotive and see how things were progressing.

When I walked in, Bill looked at me and said:

“I'm glad you came by.”

That's rarely how a conversation about an old Porsche begins when good news follows.

Then he told me we had a “boat anchor.”

I looked at him like he was speaking Greek.

Bill showed me the deck of the engine block.

Between cylinders 2 and 3, the aluminum had begun to erode. This wasn't carbon buildup. It wasn't a valve job. It wasn't another seal or bearing we could simply replace.

We had reached the end of this engine.

THE BOAT ANCHOR

Now What?

The damage between cylinders 2 and 3 changed the equation completely.

Elliott later explained that the technically correct repair would involve machining the deck surface, which meant removing the head studs and adding considerably more work and expense. He also offered another approach he had successfully used before: repairing the damaged areas with marine epoxy, flattening the surface and using copper spray on the head gasket.

Bill wasn't comfortable going down that road.

Neither was I.

The whole reason I bought a donor engine was to avoid rebuilding a questionable engine. Spending more money repairing a replacement engine that we already knew had significant problems made very little sense.

Fortunately, Elliott had sold the engine with a warranty against major defects. After seeing what Bill and Don had found, he agreed to take it back.

I asked whether he wanted us to put the head and cam tower back on before I returned it.

His answer:

“No need to reassemble.”

And just like that, the engine I thought was going to save the project was headed back to Blairsville.


BACK TO WHERE WE STARTED

Maybe the Original Engine Wasn't Finished

During all of this, Bill had been reconsidering the engine that originally came out of my 944.

When I told Elliott the donor was coming back, I mentioned something Bill had said:

He thought he might be able to salvage my original engine.

After everything we'd been through trying to replace it, perhaps the answer had been sitting there all along.