The Silver Lining

Well, Since It's Already Apart…

To be clear, this wasn't my decision..

But, there are generally two ways to remove the engine from a Porsche 944. You can pull it out through the top, or you can drop it out through the bottom.

Bill was pretty clear that dropping the engine from underneath was his preferred method, and Don agreed. Given their experience, I wasn't about to argue.

From what I understood, pulling the engine from above would have been less expensive because it wouldn't require removing as many components. But Bill and Don had their reasons, and I trusted their judgment.

As it turns out, their decision may have been a blessing in disguise.

With the engine, crossmember, and much of the front suspension removed, I suddenly had access to areas of the car that would otherwise have been difficult, if not impossible, to properly clean and restore.

The engine mounts, crossmember, suspension components, and all those hard-to-reach corners of the engine bay were now exposed. Forty-plus years of dirt, grease, and surface rust were waiting for me.

And since I'd already rebuilt the steering rack, it seemed like the perfect opportunity to give the rest of the front end some attention.

Of course, that wasn't part of the original plan.

But then again, very little about this restoration has gone according to plan.

What started as an effort to fix one cylinder has turned into something considerably bigger. And while I'm still keeping an eye on the budget, it's hard to justify putting 40-year-old dirty, rusty parts back into a freshly cleaned engine bay when everything is already sitting right in front of me.

So, was dropping the engine from underneath a good decision?

Financially, maybe not.

But from a restoration standpoint, I'm beginning to think it was.

Now comes the question I've learned to be a little more careful about asking:

How much more work could this possibly be?

The Moment of Truth

With the engine finally out of the car, Don moved it from the engine table onto an engine stand and began the process of taking it apart.

Off came the fuel rail, intake manifold, vacuum lines, and everything else that needed to be removed before we could get to the heart of the problem.

First up was another look inside cylinder #4.

Given everything we'd already been through with the replacement engine, I was more than a little nervous about what we might find. The last thing I wanted was another engine with cylinder damage that couldn't be repaired.

Fortunately, this time we got some good news.

Don scoped cylinder #4, Bill reviewed what he found, and gave us the green light to proceed.

Finally, something was going our way.

Next came the cam housing. Don removed it and, at first glance, everything appeared to be in reasonably good condition. But it was filthy inside. Not just the usual dark oil residue you'd expect from an engine that's been around for more than 40 years. This was different.

It almost looked as though something had mixed with the oil.

Don set the cam housing aside on the parts table and turned his attention to the cylinder head.

This was going to be interesting.

With the head removed, we could finally get a good look at the combustion chambers, pistons, cylinder walls, and head gasket.

As expected, there was plenty of carbon buildup. Nothing particularly surprising there.

But the head gasket was another story.

It was in terrible condition and appeared to have been leaking, potentially allowing coolant to mix with the engine oil.

And that would certainly explain what we were finding throughout the engine.

The residue wasn't quite the classic milky-looking oil you sometimes see when coolant and oil mix. It was darker and thicker, almost like a milkshake that had turned into pudding. Clumpy, dark pudding.

Not exactly what you want circulating through your engine.

Whether the head gasket was responsible for all of it still needs to be confirmed, but it was certainly beginning to look like we'd uncovered another problem that needed attention.

There was, however, some genuinely encouraging news.

The cylinder walls looked to be in good shape.

After all the concerns about cylinder #4, and the disappointment with the donor engine, that was a pretty significant development.

We weren't out of the woods yet, but at least the original engine was giving us reasons to be optimistic.

Next, Don would turn his attention to the bottom end, starting with removing the oil pan.

Given what we'd already found inside the engine, I was particularly interested in seeing what might be waiting for us down there.

Hopefully, no more pudding.

The Apprentice Gets His First Assignment

So much for hoping there wouldn't be any more pudding.

Don removed the oil pan, took one look inside, and called me over.

"Look at this."

Sitting in the bottom of the oil pan were clumps of sludge, some nearly the size of my fist.

Not exactly what we were hoping to find.

We already suspected that coolant had been mixing with the engine oil, given the condition of the head gasket and what we'd discovered in the cam housing. But seeing that much sludge accumulated in the bottom of the engine was something else entirely.

And Don was concerned.

It wasn't just what we could see in the oil pan. It was what we couldn't see.

How much of this stuff had worked its way into the hidden passages and cavities throughout the engine? Could it obstruct an oil passage? And perhaps more importantly, how could we be certain we'd cleaned it all out?

The last thing we wanted was to put everything back together, reinstall the engine, and discover that some leftover sludge had caused an oiling problem.

Suddenly, what we'd hoped would be a relatively limited engine rebuild was beginning to look a little more complicated.

In the meantime, Don had a job for me.

Clean the oil pan.

Fair enough. I was happy to contribute, and after seeing what was sitting in the bottom of it, I certainly wasn't going to argue.

So I went to work.

And I mean really went to work.

By the time I finished, that oil pan was spotless. Every bit of sludge, grime, and accumulated crud I could reach was gone. I was actually pretty pleased with myself.

Don took a look at my handiwork, chuckled, and then let me in on a little secret.

Apparently, cleaning the oil pan is exactly the kind of job that gets assigned to mechanics-in-training. The new guy. The apprentice. The person at the bottom of the shop's pecking order.

A sort of rite of passage.

Well, I suppose everyone has to start somewhere.

And for the record, I did a pretty darn good job.

Now, if only cleaning the rest of the engine were going to be that easy.

And Then There Was the Weld…

Just when I thought we'd uncovered all the surprises this engine had to offer, we found something else.

And this one wasn't good.

While inspecting the lower portion of the engine, we discovered evidence of an earlier repair to the engine block.

Someone had welded it.

And not particularly well.

The damage was near the front of the engine, in the area of the air-conditioning compressor. From what we could tell, it appeared that the compressor, or something associated with it, had taken a significant hit at some point, damaging the block.

Exactly when or how it happened was anyone's guess.

What made it particularly strange was that the car didn't show any obvious signs of a major accident. Nothing in the body or frame suggested the kind of impact that might have caused this.

But there it was. A poorly executed weld on the original engine block.

After everything we'd been through with the donor engine, this was not what I wanted to see.

We'd already abandoned one replacement engine because of cylinder damage. We'd come back to the original engine hoping that a valve job, new seals, and some careful attention would get us back on the road.

And now we had to consider whether the original block itself was even worth saving.

I couldn't help but think back to how this whole adventure started.

One cylinder with low compression.

How hard could that be to fix?

Apparently, pretty hard.

And just like that, we were back to the question I thought we'd already answered:

Do we actually have an engine we can rebuild?