the search

How Much Is an Engine?

Rebuild mine? Buy a rebuilt engine? Find a used one? Suddenly I had a whole new set of questions to answer.

How much would a fully rebuilt engine cost, sitting on a crate and delivered to my door?

How much would Bill charge to rebuild mine?

Could I even find a used engine in good condition—and, more importantly, one that I knew actually ran before it was removed from the car?

I had a lot of questions. My first call was an obvious one: Elliott at 944 Barn.

I remembered Elliott mentioning that he periodically sent engines to a guy in the Midwest who rebuilt them and sold them through 944 Safari. I messaged Elliott, got the information and started looking.

$7,000. $8,000. $10,000.

Ouch.

A professionally rebuilt engine certainly had its appeal, but those numbers were difficult to reconcile with what I had already invested in the car.

Then Elliott mentioned something considerably more interesting.

He had a running engine. Still in the car.

Had I just hit the jackpot?

A Trip Back to the Barn

A few days later I was heading north to Blairsville again.

Elliott greeted me as usual, and almost immediately we discovered a problem. He had mixed up which car he was thinking about. The running engine was in a late 1985—or 1985.2—944.

Could I make it work? Probably.

Did I want another wiring harness and another list of modifications just to make a later engine work in my early car?

Absolutely not.

That wasn't the solution I had driven to Blairsville hoping to find.

But Elliott had another possibility.

look oer there

The Other 944

Sitting nearby was another car—a 1985.1 944 Elliott had recently acquired from a local owner who was moving and wanted the car gone.

It certainly needed some love, but this was the engine configuration I was looking for.

Elliott told me the car had run, although he hadn't tried starting it since it arrived at the Barn.

There was only one logical response:

“Well...can we start it?”

The hood went up. Elliott's helper turned the key.

The engine cranked.

Nothing.

Out came a can of starting fluid. A quick spray, another turn of the key...

and it ran.

Only briefly, but it ran.

Maybe there was no fuel in the tank. Maybe there was a fuel-delivery problem. Whatever the reason, we had at least proven that the engine would fire.

But after everything I had just been through with my own engine, I wanted more than that.

I wanted numbers.

200 PSI

This deserves its own little section.

We pulled out the compression gauge.
Cylinder 1: 200 PSI.
Cylinder 2: 200 PSI.
Cylinder 3: 200 PSI.
Cylinder 4: 200 PSI.
I remember thinking that 200 PSI seemed high.
But I was standing there looking at the gauge myself. Four cylinders. Four remarkably consistent readings.
After coming from an engine with one cylinder at 40 PSI, those numbers looked pretty wonderful.
As far as I was concerned, I had found my engine.
“Deal.”

Bringing It Home

There was one problem: I couldn't take it home that day.

Elliott needed time to pull the engine, and 944Fest at VIR was approaching. So I headed back to East Cobb and waited.

The good news came just before Elliott was scheduled to leave for Virginia. The engine was out.

I hooked up my trailer and made another trip to Blairsville.

We loaded the engine, secured it for the ride home, and I headed south.

For the first time since Bill asked me whether I was committed to the car, I felt like I had a clear path forward.

I wasn't spending $7,000–$10,000 on a rebuilt engine. I wasn't committing to rebuilding my original engine without knowing how deep that rabbit hole might go.

I had an M44/02 from a 1985.1 944, an engine that had fired while still in the donor car and had shown 200 PSI across all four cylinders.

I was encouraged.

I was optimistic.

I thought I had found a good engine.