The first three cylinders were encouraging.
Cylinder 1 — 160+ PSI
Cylinder 2 — 160+ PSI
Cylinder 3 — 160+ PSI
Cylinder 4 — 40 PSI
Forty.
Bill called me.
He didn't immediately launch into an explanation of what might be wrong. Instead, he asked me a remarkably simple question:
“Are you committed to this car?”
I didn't fully appreciate what he was asking.
Looking back, I think Bill already understood that we had crossed a line. Up until now, we had been troubleshooting an old Porsche that wouldn't start. Forty PSI suggested we might be dealing with something considerably more complicated—and considerably more expensive.
But I had come this far.
“Yes.”
So Bill kept going.
The next step was a wet compression test. Bill added a small amount of oil to the cylinder and tested it again.
This time the number came up.
40 PSI became roughly 80 PSI.
That was certainly better, but nowhere near the 160-plus PSI we were seeing from the other three cylinders.
The oil had temporarily helped the cylinder seal, which gave us another piece of information. But it didn't answer the most important question:
Where was the compression going?
Bill's next diagnostic step was a leak-down test.
Rather than measuring how much pressure the engine could create while cranking, we would put compressed air into the cylinder and find out where it escaped.
And this time, the engine gave us a pretty unmistakable answer.
Air was pouring back into the air-filter box.
That pointed us toward the intake side.
The intake valve wasn't sealing.
At least now we knew where a significant part of our compression was disappearing. But we still didn't know why.
So Bill went one step further.
He scoped the cylinder.
The borescope appeared to confirm what the leak-down test had already suggested: there was a problem at the valve.
But Bill saw something else.
What appeared to be a scratch on the cylinder wall.
That introduced an entirely new—and much more troubling—possibility.
I immediately started retracing everything I had done.
Had I accidentally dropped something into the intake while the manifold was removed?
Could something have gotten in while I was cleaning the head and cam tower?
Could a small piece of debris have made its way into the cylinder and then been dragged along the cylinder wall when we tried to start the engine?
And could that same event somehow have contributed to the valve problem?
There were suddenly a lot of theories and very few answers.
Importantly, we didn't know that I had caused any of it. The engine hadn't run since I bought the car, and we had no reliable way of knowing when the damage occurred. The borescope could show us what was there; it couldn't tell us how or when it happened.
But the practical problem was the same.
If this was simply a valve problem, we could pull the cylinder head and repair it.
If that mark really represented significant damage to the cylinder wall, we could be looking at something much larger.
A complete engine rebuild.
And on a forty-two-year-old Porsche 944, that raised an uncomfortable economic question.
Do I tear down the original engine and rebuild it?
Or, rather than spending thousands rebuilding an engine we still knew relatively little about, do I find another good 2.5-liter engine and replace it?
There was, of course, a third option:
Stop.
Sell the car as a project, recover whatever I could, and accept that I had gone far enough.
I had already answered Bill's question.
I was committed.
So the question became:
And, as I was about to discover, the word “good” would become very important.